Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent visit to Israel, just days before the attack on Iran, has drawn widespread scrutiny both internationally and within India. Critics argue the trip compromised India’s diplomatic stance and appeared to favor political and business interests.
Global outlets questioned the timing and intent of Modi’s visit. Bloomberg described the trip as “suspicious and diplomatically dangerous,” while Itay Mack of The Wire called Modi a “cheap advertisement” for Israeli elections.
Several reports suggest Modi assured Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu of possible support against Iran, raising concerns about India’s neutrality in the region. Middle East Eye highlighted that the visit became political backing for Israel’s controversial government.
Alleged links to US and business interests
Retired U.S. Colonel Douglas McGregor noted that American naval ships were using Indian ports amid rising tensions with Iran, fueling speculation about Modi’s behind-the-scenes coordination. Some political observers questioned whether Modi aimed to protect the Chabahar port, where India has strategic investments linked to the Adani Group.
Allegations surfaced that Modi requested Israeli protection for these business interests, potentially prioritizing economic gains over diplomatic integrity. TRT World reported that Modi remained silent on the Iran situation, further intensifying public and international criticism.
Domestic backlash
India’s opposition called the visit a failure of foreign policy and a betrayal of Iran. Congress leaders Sonia Gandhi and Jairam Ramesh described the trip as a deviation from India’s traditional diplomatic stance.
Asaduddin Owaisi questioned whether Modi had prior knowledge of the attack, while civil society and political groups in occupied Kashmir staged protests condemning the decision. Critics argue the visit damaged India’s credibility as a reliable ally and reflected “hypocritical politics.”
Questions of priorities
Key concerns raised include:
-
Did Modi place political and business interests above national dignity?
-
Was silence on the Iran attack driven by private or corporate gain?
-
Did India’s neutrality in Middle East politics weaken as a result?
With international and domestic scrutiny growing, Modi’s Israel trip has ignited debates over India’s foreign policy priorities and the balance between diplomacy, politics, and business.
